The Truth:
This never happened. Unlike some of his less fortunate followers,
Muhammad enjoyed the protection of his powerful uncle, Abu Talib:
[The leading men of Mecca]
went to Abu Tablib
[and said] “Your nephew
has cursed our gods, insulted our religion, mocked our way of life and accused
our forefathers of error. Either you must stop him or you must let us get at
him” But Abu Talib would not relent:
The apostle continued on his way… In consequence, his relations with the
Quraish [Meccans] deteriorated and men withdrew from him in enmity.
(Ibn Ishaq/Hisham 168).
For thirteen years, the worst that ever happened to Muhammad at Mecca was that
he had dust thrown on him by a heckler and was occasionally mocked while praying
at the Kaaba. He continued to provoke the Meccans, at one point telling
them that he had come to bring them "slaughter" (Tabari
Vol. IV, page 101) This caused them to seize
Muhammad in an attempt (by one named Uqba) to "throttle" him, but he was
released unharmed almost immediately:
While they were talking thus the apostle appeared, and they leaped
upon him as one man and encircled him, saying, "I Are you the one who said
so-and·so against our gods and OUf religion?" The apostle said, "Yes, I am
the one who said that." And I saw one of them seize his robe. Then Abu
Bakr interposed himself weeping and saying, "Would you kill a man for
saying Allah is my Lord?" Then they left him. That is the worst that I ever saw the Quraish do to him. (Ibn
Ishaq/Hisham 184).
I asked 'Abdullah bin 'Amr bin Al-'As to inform me of the worst
thing the pagans had done to Allah's Apostle. He said: "While Allah's
Apostle was praying in the courtyard of the ka'ba, 'Uqba bin Abi Mu'ait came
and seized Allah's Apostle by the shoulder and twisted his garment round his
neck and throttled him severely. Abu Bakr came and seized 'Uqba's shoulder
and threw him away from Allah's Apostle and said, "Would you kill a man
because he says: 'My Lord is Allah,' and has come to you with clear Signs
from your Lord?"(Sahih Bukhari
60:339, 57:27)
Muhammad would have his opportunity to forgive the man
who had seized him when Uqba was captured, following the Battle of Badr.
According to his biographers, the prophet of Islam chose instead to have him
slaughtered even as the unarmed
prisoner begged for his life.
The Hadith also confirms that Muhammad was not physically harmed by the Meccans:
Allah's Apostle said, "Doesn't it astonish you how Allah protects me from the
Quraish's abusing and cursing? They abuse Mudhammam and curse Mudhammam while I
am Muhammad (and not Mudhamma)" (Bukhari
56:733)
As mentioned in several places, the worst indignity that Muhammad endured was an
episode in which Abu Jahl and others mocked him while he was praying by putting
the intestines of an animal on his back (Bukhari
4:241). The men who did this
were later killed by the Muslims.
Neither does the Quran provide any support
for the contemporary thesis that Muhammad suffered physical abuse at Mecca,
despite the many harsh things said about those who rejected him - the redundancy
of which is so abundant in the Quran that it comprises the majority of the
text.
There is also an entire chapter (Sura) of the Quran devoted to describing the gruesome and
sadistic torture awaiting Abu Lahab and his wife in hell, who are the only
people mentioned by name in the Quran (other than Muhammad and his son-in-law Zaid).
Yet, according to the authentic Hadith, their only crime was personal mockery of
"the Messenger" at Mecca (Muslim
406,
Bukhari 60:475).
|
